--- title: "Evaluating an MSP: The Pros and Cons of Using an RFP" description: Learn the pros and cons of using an RFP to evaluate MSPs, and discover alternative strategies for building effective managed service partnerships. image: https://blog.innovativeinc.net/hubfs/pros%20cons%20rfp%20header.png --- [![Innovative logo](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/hubfs/INNO_Wordmark_Primary_KO_RGB.png)](https://www.innovativeinc.net/) - About - [The Innovative Way](https://www.innovativeinc.net/the-innovative-way) - [Our Team](https://www.innovativeinc.net/our-team) - [Service Area](https://www.innovativeinc.net/service-area) - [Service Level Agreement (SLA)](https://www.innovativeinc.net/service-level-agreement) - [Refer a Business](https://www.innovativeinc.net/referrals) - [Careers](https://www.innovativeinc.net/careers) - Partner With Us - [innovateCORE](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-core) - [innovateAHEAD](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-ahead) - [innovateSMART](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-smart) - [innovateSTRONG](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-strong) - [innovateTRUST](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-trust) - Areas of Expertise - [Information Technology](https://www.innovativeinc.net/information-technology) - [Business Continuity & Disaster Recovery (BCDR)](https://www.innovativeinc.net/bcdr) - [Cybersecurity](https://www.innovativeinc.net/cybersecurity) - [Phone & Voice](https://www.innovativeinc.net/phone-voice) - [Printer & Copiers](https://www.innovativeinc.net/printer-copiers) - Industries - [Healthcare / HIPAA](https://www.innovativeinc.net/healthcare-hippaa) - [Manufacturing](https://www.innovativeinc.net/manufacturing) - [Nonprofit](https://www.innovativeinc.net/nonprofit) - [Professional Services](https://www.innovativeinc.net/professional-services) - [Property Management](https://www.innovativeinc.net/property-management) - Learning - [The Innovative Blog](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog) - [Press Releases](https://www.innovativeinc.net/press-releases) - [Podcast](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovative-leadership-podcast/) - [Events](https://www.innovativeinc.net/events) - [Free Cybersecurity Assessment](https://www.innovativeinc.net/cybersecurity-assessment) - About - [The Innovative Way](https://www.innovativeinc.net/the-innovative-way) - [Our Team](https://www.innovativeinc.net/our-team) - [Service Area](https://www.innovativeinc.net/service-area) - [Service Level Agreement (SLA)](https://www.innovativeinc.net/service-level-agreement) - [Refer a Business](https://www.innovativeinc.net/referrals) - [Careers](https://www.innovativeinc.net/careers) - Partner With Us - [innovateCORE](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-core) - [innovateAHEAD](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-ahead) - [innovateSMART](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-smart) - [innovateSTRONG](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-strong) - [innovateTRUST](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovate-trust) - Areas of Expertise - [Information Technology](https://www.innovativeinc.net/information-technology) - [Business Continuity & Disaster Recovery (BCDR)](https://www.innovativeinc.net/bcdr) - [Cybersecurity](https://www.innovativeinc.net/cybersecurity) - [Phone & Voice](https://www.innovativeinc.net/phone-voice) - [Printer & Copiers](https://www.innovativeinc.net/printer-copiers) - Industries - [Healthcare / HIPAA](https://www.innovativeinc.net/healthcare-hippaa) - [Manufacturing](https://www.innovativeinc.net/manufacturing) - [Nonprofit](https://www.innovativeinc.net/nonprofit) - [Professional Services](https://www.innovativeinc.net/professional-services) - [Property Management](https://www.innovativeinc.net/property-management) - Learning - [The Innovative Blog](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog) - [Press Releases](https://www.innovativeinc.net/press-releases) - [Podcast](https://www.innovativeinc.net/innovative-leadership-podcast/) - [Events](https://www.innovativeinc.net/events) - [Free Cybersecurity Assessment](https://www.innovativeinc.net/cybersecurity-assessment) - Categories - Follow Us - [Business Strategy](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/business-strategy) - [Cybersecurity](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/cybersecurity) - [Devices](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/devices) - [Disaster Recovery](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/disaster-recovery) - [Employee Retention](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/employee-retention) - [HIPAA](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/hipaa) - [Life at Innovative](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/life-at-innovative) - [Microsoft Windows](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/microsoft-windows) - [Outsourced IT Support](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/outsourced-it-support) - [Printers and Copiers](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/printers-copiers) - [Purchasing](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/purchasing) - [Technology Strategy](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/technology-strategy) - [Threat Prevention](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/threat-prevention) - - - - - [«  View All Posts](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog) ![Evaluating an MSP: The Pros and Cons of Using an RFP](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/hubfs/pros%20cons%20rfp%20header.png) ![Blog Feature](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/298890/blog-files/blog--cards-feature.png) ![Ryan Stickel](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/hubfs/Ryan%20Stickel.png "Ryan Stickel") By: [Ryan Stickel](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/author/ryan-stickel) on June 16th, 2025 Print/Save as PDF # Evaluating an MSP: The Pros and Cons of Using an RFP [Insider](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/insider) | [Business Strategy](https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/topic/business-strategy) - Share: - - - - [mailto:?body=https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/evaluating-msp-pros-cons-using-rfp](mailto:?body=https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/evaluating-msp-pros-cons-using-rfp) When evaluating a new managed service provider (MSP), a business might issue a Request for Proposal (RFP). RFPs offer structure and transparency, but they may not provide every business with what it’s looking for when it comes to managed services. Today, we will discuss RFPs and outline their pros and cons. While reading this article, please keep in mind that every organization operates differently and has its own unique needs and goals. ## What Is an RFP? A Request for Proposal is a document that outlines your organization’s technical and service requirements. It is distributed to potential vendors with the expectation that they will submit formal responses for evaluation. The goal of an RFP is to create a fair, consistent way to assess vendors. ## The Pros of Using an RFP ### Standardized Evaluation An RFP helps level the playing field. Each vendor is asked to respond to the same set of questions, making it easier to compare services, pricing and capabilities side-by-side. ### Clear Documentation RFPs encourage internal clarity. Creating one requires your team to define its needs, priorities and desired outcomes before you even talk to vendors. That process alone can be valuable for a business when setting goals and forming a technology strategy. ### Compliance Requirements For organizations in regulated industries or those with formal purchasing policies, an RFP provides a documented and auditable process that meets oversight requirements. ## The Cons of Using an RFP ### Resource-Heavy Process RFPs require significant time and energy, from drafting the document to managing vendor communications and evaluating responses. For smaller teams, this can lengthen the decision-making process. ### Limited Conversations RFPs describe the needs an organization thinks they have, but MSPs can offer valuable insights by helping to uncover needs you might not even realize exist! When the format is too rigid, it can hinder that beneficial conversation. ### Not All Vendors Participate Some providers may not engage in RFPs, particularly if the process seems overly focused on price or if they suspect the outcome is predetermined. That could mean missing out on high-quality partners. ### Overemphasis on Price The structure of an RFP can prioritize cost over long-term value. While managing expenses is important, the cheapest provider isn’t always the best choice, especially for a strategic service like IT management. ## When an RFP Might Make Sense In some cases, an RFP can be the right tool. It may be worth pursuing if: - Your organization has strict procurement or compliance requirements. - You have a well-defined, specific technical scope. - You’re confident your internal team has the time to manage the process. - You’re evaluating a short-term engagement or clearly defined project. However, for long-term managed services partnerships, where accountability, fit and collaboration matter just as much as scope, an RFP alone may be too rigid to identify the best partner. ## What to Consider Instead Instead of starting with an RFP, consider starting with discovery calls with a few pre-qualified providers. These conversations allow vendors to understand your business goals and propose solutions aligned with your long-term needs, not just your immediate requests. From there, if you still want a formal comparison, you can request proposals in a more streamlined format, without the time and complexity of a full RFP process. ## Start with a Conversation RFPs offer structure and transparency, but they aren’t the only path to selecting the right MSP. For relationship-based services like IT support and management, the most effective partnerships often start with an open and honest conversation, not a form.  [![New call-to-action](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/5078717/2850556d-8c66-4683-9506-c91625c43ddd.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/5078717/2850556d-8c66-4683-9506-c91625c43ddd) - - - - [mailto:?body=https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/evaluating-msp-pros-cons-using-rfp](mailto:?body=https://blog.innovativeinc.net/blog/evaluating-msp-pros-cons-using-rfp) #### Contact **Headquarters** 13332 Pennsylvania Ave. Hagerstown, MD 21742 [301-739-7414](tel:+13017397414) **Washington, DC** 1717 K Street NW, Suite 900 Washington, DC 20006 [202-971-9991](tel:+12029719991) #### Managed Services - [Managed Services](https://www.innovativeinc.net/services) - [Co-Managed Services](https://www.innovativeinc.net/co-managed-services) - [Service Level Agreement](https://www.innovativeinc.net/service-level-agreement) - [Pricing](https://www.innovativeinc.net/pricing) - [Service Area](https://www.innovativeinc.net/service-area) #### Areas of Expertise - [Information Technology](https://www.innovativeinc.net/information-technology) - [BCDR](https://www.innovativeinc.net/bcdr) - [Cybersecurity](https://www.innovativeinc.net/cybersecurity) - [Phone & Voice](https://www.innovativeinc.net/phone-voice) - [Printer & Copiers](https://www.innovativeinc.net/printer-copiers) #### About - [About](https://www.innovativeinc.net/the-innovative-way) - [Our Team](https://www.innovativeinc.net/our-team) - [Privacy Policy](https://www.innovativeinc.net/privacy-) - [Contact](https://www.innovativeinc.net/contact) - [Book an Appointment](https://meetings.hubspot.com/shurd?uuid=e72ba9dd-044e-4670-8593-c28ca53244eb)